Surplus: The History of Too Much and the End of Economic Primacy
The Puzzle
The United
States carries more than $40.5 trillion of debt. Neither party has the appetite
to address it. Yet adjusted for inflation, real interest rates remain subdued.
While nominal yields are near multi-decade highs, real yields are modest. The
US 10-year yield is a little below 4.95% now, and US CPI was 3.7% in
September.
Scarcity
cannot explain this. There is too much capital chasing too few outlets, and
that is the argument of Surplus.
The S&P 500 could fund the entire $5.2 trillion AI build-out with about 2.5
years of profits. Buybacks happen not because senior executives are generous;
US corporations are now net lenders. Return the hot potato, the surplus capital
to investors. Let them figure out what to do with it.
Politics and
Economics Rejoined
Harold
Lasswell, a founder of modern political science, defined politics as "who
gets what, when and how." To the modern ear that sounds like economics.
It should. The
book belongs to a tradition that treats the two as inseparable. Economics is
not a value-neutral metric standing above politics. It is value-laden and
grounded in society.
My book offers
an accessible reframing of both.
Three
Economies, One Condition
Agricultural
surplus made industrialization possible. Industrial surplus made possible the
surplus of capital itself.
Most observers
treat surplus as a special case: state planning in China, or overcapacity in
steel and autos. But it is the general condition, I argue. Capitalism has
become victim of its own successes.
The American
surplus, along with the portion of the world's excess savings that US firms
manage, flows into financial markets liberated since the 1980s. Japan has
exported its surplus for decades, less as goods than as savings. China
reinvests its surplus in industrial capacity and exports goods.
Three
economies, three channels, one phenomenon.
Capitalism
creates values and interests, not only goods and services. Think of Abraham
Maslow's hierarchy of needs. After decades of relative peace and prosperity
across North America, Europe, and much of Asia, the basic needs of many are
met. Other needs and interests have emerged.
National
security, the environment, and social justice have grown more salient. They
challenge the primacy we have given economic values for a couple of generations.
Freedom and
Equality
My deepest
interest is freedom and equality.
I return to
the classic meaning of freedom that inspired the American founders: the right
to participate in shaping the community in which one lives. In recent decades
it has been narrowed to liberty, which means property rights.
I tested this
at New York University's Center for Global Affairs, where I taught for many
years. I asked students to imagine that the government decided tomorrow there
were too many breakfast cereals, and that from now on there would be three: one
that gets soggy in milk, one that does not, and a healthy granola. How many
would feel less free?
Every
semester, an overwhelming majority said they would.
Freedom had
become the menu. Choice among goods is mistaken for self-determination.
An Old
Conversation
I am
continuing another dialogue that began long ago, with Keynes's The End of Laissez-Faire (1926)
and Peter Drucker's The End of
Economic Man (1939). Neither granted capital special powers. It was
a factor of production, subject to the same forces as any other.
The End of
Economic Primacy, the book's subtitle, takes the next step. Capital has reached the
point other goods and services reached: diminishing marginal utility. When
there is enough, the next unit is worth less, and the next less again.
Drucker showed
how economic despair feeds authoritarianism. I worry that the pendulum swung so
far toward liberty that it undermined equality. A profound sense of unfairness
now cuts across demographics, income levels, and national frontiers.
Surplus is
published by Prometheus today, Election Day. It is not coincidental. The
election itself speaks to a critical theme of the book: The top 100 Americans' share of federal election spending has risen from 0.25% in 2000 to 7.5% in
2024.
The Question
Surplus Asks
For three
centuries, economics asked how to produce more. It was the right question while
scarcity ruled. Keynes anticipated the "economic problem"(scarcity)
would be solved by 2030. We have conquered scarcity ahead of schedule, as it
were. Now what?
We can produce
more than the arrangements built to distribute it can absorb. The surplus is
not the problem. It is the evidence that the old question is spent.
A society that
can make everything but cannot say what it is for will fill the silence with
the only language it has left: price. That is how a breakfast aisle comes to
stand for freedom.
The new
question is political, as it always was. Who belongs? Who is us? What does
membership guarantee? What can we give each other when there is enough?
We are not short of capital. We
are short of answers. Surplus is the history of how we got here, and the
argument for what comes next.
We either find
a new synthesis of freedom and equality, or we will surely face the demons
Drucker saw.
Order today:
https://www.globepequot.com/9781493096657/surplus/
Reviewed by Marc Chandler
on
November 03, 2026
Rating:


